Home About
Services
Homes Emergency Plumbing Drain Cleaning Hydro Jetting Leak Detection Leak Repair Slab Leak Repair Sewer Line Repair Sewer Line Replacement Water Heater Repair Water Heater Installation Tankless Water Heater Repair Tankless Water Heater Installation Repiping Copper Repiping Water Filtration Whole House Water Filtration Water Softener Installation Gas Line Installation Gas Line Repair Bathroom Plumbing Kitchen Plumbing New Construction Plumbing Plumbing Inspections Boiler Repair
Septic Septic Service Septic Tank Pumping Septic Tank Installation Septic Tank Repair Septic Inspection Leach Lines Leach Line Installation Leach Line Repair Excavation Grease Traps Grease Trap Cleaning Grease Trap Installation Grease Trap Repair Pump Installation Pump Replacement
Business Commercial Drain Cleaning Commercial Sewer Repair Commercial Hydro Jetting Commercial Water Heaters Commercial Repiping Commercial Leak Detection Commercial Leak Repair Commercial Water Line Repair Commercial Water Line Installation Commercial New Construction Backflow Installation Backflow Prevention Office Building Plumbing Apartment Complex Plumbing Hotel Plumbing Plumbing Products and Fixtures
Industrial Industrial Water Systems Industrial Drainage Systems Industrial Hydro Jetting Emergency Industrial Plumbing
Areas
San Bernardino County San Bernardino County Yucaipa San Bernardino Colton Grand Terrace Rialto Fontana Rancho Cucamonga Upland Ontario Montclair Chino Chino Hills Hesperia Apple Valley Victorville Adelanto
Riverside County Riverside County Calimesa Beaumont Banning Moreno Valley Riverside Jurupa Valley Eastvale Norco Corona Perris Menifee San Jacinto Hemet Lake Elsinore Canyon Lake Wildomar Palm Springs Desert Hot Springs Cathedral City Rancho Mirage Palm Desert Indian Wells La Quinta
Los Angeles County Los Angeles County Pomona Claremont La Verne San Dimas Diamond Bar Walnut Covina Glendora Azusa West Covina Baldwin Park Duarte Bradbury
Gallery Blog Contact
Call · (909) 888-8736
Skip to content

What Turns Up Under an Old Toilet

Pulling a toilet is one of those jobs that sounds small until the thing is off the floor. Underneath is the part nobody has seen in decades: the flange that holds it down, the wax ring that seals it, and in an older house a cast iron fitting that has been carrying everything since the day the house was built. Sometimes it all looks fine. Sometimes the fitting comes up cracked and packed with rust scale. Pull one up in an older house and there is often a wax ring flattened to nothing and a cast iron fitting full of scale.

A toilet that rocks is telling you something

Sit down and feel the toilet shift, even a little, and it is worth paying attention to. A toilet is supposed to sit solid on the floor, bolted to a flange that is fastened to the drain below. When it rocks, one of those things has let go. The bolts may have worked loose, the flange may be cracked or rusted through, or the floor under it may have gone soft.

Rocking matters because of the seal. Every time the toilet moves, it works the wax ring underneath, and a ring that has been squashed and shifted enough times stops sealing. Then a little water gets out with every flush. You might see it as a stain creeping out around the base, a smell that will not go away no matter how often the bathroom gets cleaned, or flooring that feels spongy right next to the bowl. Snugging the bolts can hide the rocking for a while, but if the flange underneath is broken, the toilet will be loose again before long and the seal will be worse for it.

The flange and the wax ring

The flange is a ring fastened to the floor that the drain pipe comes up through, and the toilet bolts down to it. In older homes it might be cast iron, brass or plastic, depending on when the bathroom was last redone. The wax ring sits between the toilet and the flange and seals the gap so nothing leaks out and no sewer gas comes up into the room.

Wax rings do not last forever, and they do not survive being disturbed. Any time a toilet comes up, the old ring gets scraped off and a new one goes on. Flanges are a different story. A good one can be reused. A cracked one, one with broken bolt slots, or one sitting too low under a new floor needs repair or replacement, or the toilet will never seat right.

Floor height catches a lot of people during a remodel. Put new tile down over the old floor and the flange can end up below the finished surface, which is a problem for the seal that is easy to fix before the toilet goes back on and a pain to fix after.

Cast iron that cracks and scales shut

Below the flange in a lot of older houses is cast iron, often a curved fitting called a closet bend that turns the drain from straight down toward the main line. Cast iron holds up a long time, but it does wear out. The inside rusts and builds up scale, a rough crust that narrows the opening and catches paper and waste. The fitting can also crack, from age, from settling, or from years of a loose toilet working on it.

We have pulled fittings out from under toilets during a bathroom rebuild that were packed with rust scale and split along the side. A toilet sitting on that will flush slow, clog more than it should, and may be leaking into the floor below the seal where nobody can see it. You might never know until the floor goes soft or the room below picks up a stain.

Our bathroom plumbing work around Highland runs into this in older homes all the time, and it is the main reason we like to see what is under a toilet before anybody sets a new one.

Why the remodel is the time to replace it

If you are redoing a bathroom and the floor is coming up anyway, that is the cheapest moment you will ever get to deal with what is under the toilet. The tile is off, the subfloor is showing, and the old drain fittings are sitting right there. Replacing a cracked or scaled cast iron bend at that stage is a small piece of the job.

Wait until later and it is a different job. Somebody has to pull up brand new tile, cut into a finished floor, and then match it and patch it all back. That is a lot of trouble over a fitting that could have been swapped while the room was already torn apart.

So when your remodel reaches the floor, have someone look before anything new goes down. Check the flange, the fitting under it, the drain run toward the main, and the shower and tub drains while the floor is open. Old cast iron in one spot usually means old cast iron nearby, and finding it now keeps it from being the reason your new bathroom gets opened back up a few years in.

Hard water and the rest of the bathroom

Inland Empire water is hard, and a bathroom shows it everywhere. The minerals that build up inside a water heater also collect in every small opening in the room. The aerator on the sink faucet clogs and the stream turns sputtery. Shower heads lose holes one at a time until the spray goes sideways. The cartridge inside a shower valve gets crusty and stiff, so the handle fights you or the temperature drifts while you are standing there.

Toilets get it too. Scale builds up inside the fill valve and around the flapper, and a toilet that runs on its own or refills every few minutes is often a seal that minerals have roughened up. You will hear it hiss at night. Some of this is easy homeowner work, like soaking an aerator or shower head to loosen the buildup. Valve cartridges and fill valves are worth having replaced once they start acting up. More of what we handle in the bathroom, from the toilet to the shower valve, is on our bathroom plumbing page.

Questions from people standing over a toilet

Is a little water around the base of the toilet a big deal?

It can be. If it is not condensation or a splash, water at the base usually means the seal underneath has failed, and some of that water is getting into the floor every time you flush. Over time it softens the subfloor and can rot it out. It is a lot easier to reset a toilet than to replace a floor.

Can I replace a wax ring myself?

Plenty of handy people do. Shut off the water at the valve behind the toilet, flush it to drain the tank, pull the bolts and lift it straight up. The part to watch is what you find underneath. If the flange is cracked or the cast iron below it is broken, a new wax ring will not fix it, and that is when to call us.

Where is the water shutoff for my bathroom?

Each toilet and sink usually has a small valve on the wall or floor behind it, which shuts off just that fixture. Showers and tubs often do not have one. For those, and for anything bigger, you need the main shutoff for the house, so find it now and make sure it turns before the day you need it.

If your toilet rocks, runs or leaves water at the base, or your remodel is about to reach the floor, call the shop at (909) 888-8736 or tell us what you are seeing. We will look at what is under there and tell you plainly what needs replacing.